Artificial Intelligence Law And Digitalisation In Law

The Use Of AI Systems Within The Context Of The Offence Of Conducting Statistical Analysis Based On The Identity Of Judges Under French Law

This paper investigates a specific criminal offence under French law, for which AI systems may be frequently and effectively used: the statistical analysis of judicial decisions based on the identities of judges and court clerks. Emerging from France’s open data policy and formalised through the Digital Republic Act adopted in 2016, the public dissemination of judicial decisions has become increasingly widespread. While this development advances transparency and democratic accountability, it simultaneously gives rise to significant concerns regarding privacy and the protection of personal data. In response to these risks, the French legislature amended Article L10 of the Administrative Justice Act and Article L111-13 of the Judicial Organisation Act in 2019 to criminalise the reuse of identity data from judicial actors for the purpose of or, with the effect of, evaluating or predicting their professional practices. The offence, classified as a misdemeanour (délit) under the French Penal Code, carries penalties of imprisonment and substantial fines. This paper examines the offence’s material and moral elements, its place within the broader structure of French criminal law, and the potential for AI technologies to give rise to liability. It demonstrates that the French legal framework reflects a deliberate prioritisation of data protection and judicial independence over algorithmic optimisation and predictive utility.

Mustafa Akgün
DOI: 10.53478/TUBA.978-625-6110-66-3.ch02