Artificial Intelligence Law And Digitalisation In Law

The Liability Maze In AI-Generated Intellectual Property Violations

The rapid deployment of generative artificial intelligence systems reveals fundamental deficiencies in legal frameworks designed for human creativity, hence generating unprecedented challenges for intellectual property law. This study examines how artificial intelligence systems that generate potentially infringing outputs and are trained on billions of copyrighted works have transformed established liability regimes across several nations. The analysis of the complex AI ecosystem, encompassing model developers, training data providers, platform operators, and end users, reveals that conventional liability theories are inadequate due to the scale, opacity, and automated nature of AI operations. The opaque nature of artificial intelligence systems, along with its memorization phenomenon, obstructs efforts to establish clear causal relationships between training inputs and potentially erroneous outputs. Initial judicial responses, such as Kneschke v. LAION and Thomson Reuters v. Ross Intelligence, with the concerning integration of web scraping with text and data mining in recent Hungarian case law, illustrate the difficulties courts have in adapting conventional copyright principles to artificial intelligence contexts. A comparative jurisdictional analysis uncovers fundamental disparities in policy methodologies. The European Union's comprehensive strategy, which integrates the rights reservation mechanism of the DSM Directive with the transparency mandates of the AI Act, starkly contrasts with the United States' reliance on fair use doctrine and litigation-based advancement. Divergent aims distinctly reflect contrasting models from Japan and China, suggesting that world unity is unlikely. These various methodologies provide distinct challenges for global artificial intelligence systems that must navigate conflicting legal duties across countries. The paper introduces a pragmatic multi-stakeholder responsibility framework that acknowledges technology limitations and political realities instead of proposing definitive solutions. Acknowledging that complete prevention of infringement may be technically unfeasible due to current artificial intelligence capabilities, the framework replaces negligence-based standards with stringent liability grounded in enhanced due diligence obligations. It emphasizes documented good faith efforts above guaranteed outcomes, proportional responsibility based on stakeholder sophistication and control, and adaptable systems capable of evolving with technological advancements. The paper concludes that, despite inherent uncertainties, effective AI liability frameworks must integrate incentives for innovation with the safeguarding of rights. To achieve success, one must go beyond the current dichotomy between authoritarian and liberal policies and establish more malleable rules that provide sufficient security without stifling the development of AI that serves society well. The challenge is in creating sustainable methods to manage the ongoing tension between legal obligations and technology capabilities, rather than in achieving optimal solutions.

Muhammed Furkan Akıncı
DOI: 10.53478/TUBA.978-625-6110-66-3.ch03